Articles published in June, 2009

  1. Media training lessons from Jetstar

    Published on Friday, June 26th, 2009

    While the saga of Jetstars’ stranded All Black fans became a communications quagmire, with
    claim and counter-claim, there is one particular element we would like to reflect upon. It is the way Jetstar’s spokesperson responded to questions about the incident during an interview with Radio NZ’s Morning Report last Monday.

    Jetstar’s spokeman Simon Westaway was not prepared to give any ground, let alone apologise.  The key messages were:  These people were late; we will debate this any time anywhere; we carry 12 million people a year.

    To paraphrase: No ifs or buts, we were right; these people were wrong.

    This approach even seemed to ruffle Morning Report’s nice guy Geoff Robinson, and was almost certainly the reason for on-going criticisms of the airline, some of which became quite toxic in the online space.

    Jetstar seems to have seriously misread the New Zealand culture as, in all likelihood, a local company and a local spokesperson would have been more conciliatory with messages like:
    We take all complaints seriously; we will review the matter thoroughly and examine our processes; and If we are wrong, we’ll take it on the chin and talk to these customers about making it right. (Apparently there was CCTV footage that could be reviewed).

    Such an approach would have de-escalated the situation which quickly went from simmering to boiling.

    If you are going to adopt this staunch, brash approach – no nonsense, no vacillation, let’s move on – just be sure you’re bulletproof… Today (Friday), Jetstar’s own reported actions suggest the airline did make some errors.  They are apologising to some customers, offering discount vouchers and reviewing their check-in performance.

    Public 1, Jetstar 0

  2. Backed into a corner

    Published on Friday, June 26th, 2009

    Backed into a corner, Mathieu Bastareaud finally admitted he lied about being attacked in Wellington.  Many of you will be asking: when will the French learn?

    New Zealand is a small community.   Our Police do not operate like the Pink Panther; no one should ever underestimate how seriously we take our reputation.

    Maybe it is because Mathieu Bastareaud was not born when some of his compatriots blew up the Rainbow Warrior, but he has carried on a tradition of severely underestimating our thorough policing skills. The French crack agents got caught, but not before they had enjoyed a Gallic serving of wine, women and song.

    It’s what we love about the French.  Their insouciance, their devil may care attitude, their First Lady.

    We hear that young Mathieu, who claims to be suffering from depression as a result of his mis-speak is now holidaying in the Caribbean.  Things get tough – take a holiday.  Remember that was also the solution for the agents.

    They say history never repeats.

    Incidentally, Morning Report’s, Sean Plunket was one of the very few media who earlier in the week questioned the authenticity of the claim.  At the time the police response should have given the French rugby administrators a clue to what we now know.

    Viva La France? On this occasion may be not.

  3. Who controls the message? Can Anyone?

    Published on Thursday, June 25th, 2009

    Despite Iran being a tightly controlled Islamic theocracy in which dissent is not tolerated, the message that the recent presidential elections were rigged gets out. Violent demonstrations ensue, which the authorities harshly try to put down, but they continue. In a standard measure to stop the protests, Iranian authorities try to shut down all communications, leaving only official channels open.

    But this is 2009 and things are different now.  Despite no access to radio, television or newspapers and with even the mobile phone network closed down, Iranian opposition is able to regroup and organise.

    The violent demonstrations continue and to the incumbent regime’s dismay, news of them leaked out. How? The Internet is the new conduit, one that the authoritarian regime cannot suppress or censor.

    Iranians desiring democracy upload raw and uncensored video clips to YouTube, using the micro-blogging service Twitter to disseminate information, share pictures and of course, email and web pages everywhere.

    When Neda, a 27-year-old woman is shot at random by a member of the state-controlled Basji militia and dies in her father’s arms, the world gets to know about it instantly. It’s a horrible spectacle, one that galvanises the opposition and one that cannot be swept under the carpet by Iran’s authorities no matter how hard they try. She has become the face of the conflict.

    As if we needed any reminder, events in Iran confirm technological change in communication means we now live in a truly open global society. With its proliferation of platforms, it appears that The Internet has arrived as the truly ‘uncontrollable’ communication forum. As communication professionals and global citizens we must be mindful of its power.

  4. Food Inc only a point of view

    Published on Monday, June 22nd, 2009

    Food IncThe movie Food Inc will be screened soon in New Zealand. It’s likely to excite a few, exasperate others, and cause many more to think about the future of our food, where it comes from and what the future holds,  especially the growing number among us who have little or no idea about where our food comes from.

    This movie will remind us how important it is to consider the origins of what it is we put in our mouths and feed to our children. As such Food Inc should be regarded as part of a wider debate on food production.

    From what we’ve seen and read, the movie is based on a brace of conspiracy theories relating to food production ownership and food quality.  The past is portrayed as good and present as a pastoral fantasy.  As always, the truth will be somewhere in the middle.

    The film makes the point that today’s food industry bears little resemblance to that of 50 years ago.  That’s probably not a bad thing when we compare the meat freezing companies of New Zealand 50 years ago with those of today. I know the environment I prefer, so there’s no nostalgia there.

    There are conspiracies, and some are potentially damaging to New Zealand, such as the romance spun by the food miles lobby.  Food miles are a thinly veiled trade barrier, the major victim of which are the poorer emerging nations.  Food miles are also in the philosophical mix of farmers markets which in most instances are too “rich” for the average punter. The Otara market is more realistic.

    The thing to remember with Food Inc is that much of it is about another country, and won’t apply here – after all we can still get meat with bones (as I’m sure you still can in the US).

    Parts of the New Zealand food industry have suffered before from imported shows about food.  Jamie Oliver did a huge disservice to our chicken nuggets when he banged on in his school dinners programme about their very different composition in the UK.  Here nuggets took a hit that was not justified.

    For those inclined to see Food Inc, remember it is a point of view, not the only view.

    www.safefoodinc.org

    Food Inc Official Trailer

  5. Pondering the swine flu

    Published on Friday, June 19th, 2009

    SpeidiThere are two things I ponder about the swine flu.  Can the precautions we take make any real difference?  How long will our media sustain the almost-hourly case count, particularly as later today our overburdened health authorities’ switch from their containment strategy to a management strategy?

    Well, actually there is a third question, none of us wants to appear selfish, but if and when we contract this disease, will there be any Tamiflu tablets left?

    To give them credit, our media have made a good fist of passing on to us the handy hints for avoidance and treatment from the Ministry of Health. However the media’s serious interest won’t last.  My cue for this is the Australian media. Victoria has become the swine flu capital of the South Pacific, and it appears they’ve stopped counting long since. Their focus now is on quirky stories like the stir-crazy Australian lacrosse team quarantined in South Korea.

    The media for good or for ill want to take polarizing positions. So one news organisation will run the ‘swine flu’ is overhyped angle and use the not related comparison of  ‘y2k’  as evidence, their competitor will focus on the growing disruptive cost of the flu and its victim count.  Then they’ll swap angles until they get tired.

    It seems that an important frontier of managing this flu is the workplace, and the key to this is clear communications to staff and management about their obligations to their workmates, i.e. keep away if you’ve got flu symptoms.  These messages need to be reinforced, particularly among those segments of the workforce where staying at home may mean being out of work and unpaid.  Maybe such people will have to be cut some slack in the interests of their workmates?

    I don’t think we will all get swine flu, or even 60% of us, if we take care of ourselves and others.

  6. Giving is in the blood

    Published on Thursday, June 11th, 2009

    It seems every day brings a new cause to support. Charities are constantly pushing their barrow into our lives with some national awareness month, week, day, hour, minute, second…whatever.  Ads with desperately cute but painfully sad looking children appear everywhere, designed to tug at the heart strings – and more often than not the wallet.  Amongst this torrent of worthy persuasion, is a communications professional poised to bombard every newsdesk in town to drive their message home.

    For all not-for-profits the challenge of influencing journalists and convincing media decision-makers of the value of your cause is relentless. Sometimes it can be met with an air of indifference. Indeed a recent conversation with one particular journalist went something like this… “I need something more newsworthy. Find me someone who’s dying!”

    In working at Network PR I’ve been able to work for the NZ Blood Service (NZBS), and I know from personal experience the importance of blood donation.  My grandmother passed away twelve years ago after a long illness, but without the people who donated the blood she regularly received, she would have died a lot sooner.

    World Blood Donor Day is the NZ Blood Service’s main annual campaign and happens to be celebrated in this country on Friday 12 June.  The campaign is largely driven by the World Health Organisation who decides on its annual theme.  As in other years, we have the challenge of creating attention.

    One of the pluses for the New Zealand Blood Service is its point of difference: it is not seeking money. And in the current climate this is quite significant. People who donate blood save lives – simple as that.  And all it costs is about an hour of time.

    Currently around 4% of New Zealanders donate blood without incentive or remuneration.  Some have their own personal stories for this. Others simply donate for no other reason than it’s a good thing to do.

    Annually around 42,000 people need this blood, many unexpectedly, others regularly. Statistically there is a good chance we’ll all have a need for blood at some point.

    As far as I’m concerned that’s the best reason of all for taking special note of World Blood Donor Day and the work of the NZ Blood Service.

  7. Focusing on what’s worth it

    Published on Friday, June 5th, 2009

    There is nothing like a good whiff of alleged sexual impropriety to liberate the minds and pens of our parliamentary hacks, and titivate the masses.

    Regrettably in the early stages of such sagas there are always more questions than answers, and as our fledging Prime Minister has found no sooner is one curly questions or innuendo dispatched, than his answer has spawned a dozen more.

    It is not our intention to make light of the plight of the hapless and now ex-minister Worth, or those he’s alleged to have pressed his unwanted-ness upon, but there is one emerging aspect of this matter that deserves a quick squashing.

    Sadly when a feeding frenzy is on, anything and anyone associated with the target may appear fair game. This led to the media to seize upon Worth’s engagement of professional communications support as though this were another indiscretion.  The truth is when all hell has broken around you, that’s exactly when you need professional advice and support, including assistance in dealing with the media.

    So, to the media we would say, let’s keep things professional and focused on the real issues.

  8. Danger money

    Published on Thursday, June 4th, 2009

    Gulf WarI never thought that I’d end up working as a journalist. In fact I vowed I wouldn’t. Like many of us, as a teen I lost a dear friend and his untimely, accidental death became the front page lead in the New Zealand Herald. I was livid and so was his family.  It seemed so unjust and invasive that his dying was the business of anyone else. My friend had drowned in a known danger spot and the story, although painful and in this case reported inaccurately and sensationally, was news. It was news because it brought home the very real danger of swimming on a treacherous beach on a day when the beach was closed due to massive seas.

    I often wondered if the reporter who trudged out to the west coast that day ever knew how the family felt, how much the presence of a news team in their private grief was despised. But reporters have to be where the trouble is, that’s their job. In a new media environment littered with stories of closing newspapers and shrinking circulation it’s easy to forget that everyday journalists, photographers and cameraman put their lives and well-being on the line to bring the rest of us the stories and the pictures.

    Keeping us mindful of this is Jim Macmillan, a US photojournalist who became so traumatised by his 30 year career that he had a crippling breakdown. After decades of forcing his way into the nightmare zones like the Oklahoma bombing and the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina it was finally the experience of being one of the first on the scene after a second plane hit the World Trade Centre that unwound him. Jim Macmillan had to acknowledge the deep psychological distress he was suffering in a journalistic culture that admires hard bitten bravado above all else. He now lectures on the effects of post traumatic stress and was recently in New Zealand addressing a group at Auckland University. What is of particular note is that it is often the young reporters who are sent out to gather the news of crimes, road accidents and disaster without the experience or support to temper the everyday brutality.

    As communication professionals we shouldn’t lose sight of fact that the news gathering process is done by people. People in the frontline, at the crash scene, in the war zones, who can be harmed by what they see and hear and what they need to make palatable for us at home.  And while we comfortably discuss in what medium we like to receive our morning news messages there are thankfully still people on the ground making it so.