I expect that you, like me, have been fascinated by the liberal dollops of advice currently being offered to political leaders of all persuasion by various members of the media. For example, just yesterday in the New Zealand Herald, the Greens were advised they needed to be “more hard-edged”, and the Dominion Post in its editorial urged Labour leader David Shearer to spell out his aspirations least he waste his honeymoon period.
The funny thing is the Greens gained 11 percent of the vote presumably without being hard-edged, and Shearer debuted at 10 percent in the preferred Prime Minister stakes, presumably aspirational-less.
If it were any other organisation preferring such advice, it might attract the criticism of being a vested interest. Why not the political media, you might wonder, particularly when politics is one of the most cost-effective sources of media content.
The reality is Labour’s Shearer is showing a “new way”. By resisting the urge to rush headlong into every fleeting issue, he is demonstrating he is prepared to listen and take a considered approach. He wants to be a spokesperson, not an answer-person. I agree with veteran journalist Richard Long (ex-Dominion Post editor) that he need not give a toss about the day-to-day point scoring in the House. There is, after all, plenty of time until the next election.
And as for the Greens, their success may well lay in not me-tooing the hard edged stuff that has characterised traditional politics and parties. It is enough that they have traded their ill-fitting morris dancing gear for business attire.
For Shearer and the Greens, keeping their own counsel may be the best course of action. What do you think?



St Matthew-in-the-City sees the Christmas season as an opportunity to spark thought and conversation in the community. They’ve put up their 



